Whitey's Ice Cream Menu
Ice Cream Flavors
Black cherry flavored ice cream with Bing cherries mixed throughout.
Black raspberry flavored ice cream with a hard chocolate swirl.
Black Raspberry Chip
Black walnut flavored ice cream mixed with black walnut pieces.
Blue colored, citrus flavored ice cream mixed with miniature marshmallows.
Bubble gum flavored ice cream mixed with pieces of real gum.
Butter flavored ice cream with butter-roasted pecans mixed throughout.
Light cinnamon flavored ice cream with cream cheese frosted homemade carrot cake pieces.
Whitey’s own rich Dutch chocolate ice cream.
Light cherry flavored ice cream with fudge swirled throughout and chocolate covered cherry pieces.
Chocolate Cherry Bon Bon
Vanilla ice cream loaded with two different kinds of chocolate chips.
Brown sugar flavored ice cream mixed with chocolate chips and real cookie dough pieces.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Dark chocolate flavored ice cream matched with fudge swirls and mixed with fudge brownie pieces.
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Chocolate flavored ice cream with brownie bits mixed in and peanut butter swirled throughout.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Revel
Coconut ice cream mixed with chocolate-covered almonds.
Pink and blue colored ice cream with cotton candy flavoring.
KONA® coffee flavored ice cream ribboned with espresso fudge swirls and a chocolate espresso chip.
Cup O' Joe Espresso®
A creamy frozen dessert made with coconut cream and mixed with cocoa and the perfect blend of mint.
Dairy-Free Chocolate Mint
Eggnog flavored ice cream with nutmeg and rum flavoring.
Vanilla ice cream with egg yolks added for a richer flavor. Available in pints and quarts only.
Chocolate flavored ice cream with coconut, pecans, brownie pieces and caramel revel swirled through
German Chocolate Cake
Graham cracker flavored ice cream with crunchy graham cracker swirled throughout.
Graham Central Station
Light raspberry flavored ice cream loaded with Gummy Bears®.
Green, mint flavored ice cream with two kinds of chocolate chips mixed throughout.
Mint Chocolate Chip
KONA® coffee flavored ice cream matched with fudge swirls and mixed with OREO® cookie bits.
Mississippi Mud Revel
Peanut butter ice cream with chunks of peanut butter oatmeal cookies, chocolate chips and M&M’s
Vanilla ice cream with heavy fudge swirled throughout, mixed with chocolate covered peanut butter cups.
Orange flavored sherbet.
Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter cookie revel and pieces of chocolate covered pretzel bark.
Peanut Butter Pretzel Bark
Peppermint flavored ice cream mixed with peppermint candy bits.
Peppermint flavored ice cream mixed with OREO® cookie pieces.
Light butter pecan flavored ice cream with swirls of caramel, pecans and praline pecans (candy-coated pecans).
Pumpkin flavored ice cream cooked with our special recipe which includes pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, eggs, and milk.
Lightly salted caramel ice cream with a caramel ribbon.
Camouflaged ice cream made with graham cracker and marshmallow ice cream with a ribbon of fudge, giving it a s'more taste.
Fresh strawberries swirled in a strawberry flavored ice cream.
Cream cheese flavored ice cream with strawberries swirled throughout and mixed with candy-coated graham cracker bits.
Chocolate flavored ice cream mixed with chocolate-covered almonds.
Swiss Almond Chocolate
Made with Whitey’s exclusive pure Madagascar vanilla bean flavoring.
Watermelon flavored sherbet.
White chocolate flavored ice cream with red raspberry swirled throughout and mixed with raspberry chocolate almond flakes.
White Chocolate Raspberry
Vanilla flavored ice cream mixed with fudge swirls and chunks of OREO® cookies.
White Tiger Paws
Made with fresh bananas. Available in pre-packaged quarts only.
Fresh banana ice cream with a graham cracker revel.
Coconut cream flavored ice cream with coconut flakes, toasted coconut and crushed pineapple.
Vanilla ice cream mixed with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces and a caramel ribbon
Caramel Waffle Cone
Coffee flavored ice cream with Heath bar pieces and a fudge swirl.
Vanilla flavored ice cream full of chocolate honeycomb pieces and rippled with a caramel swirl.
Lime flavored ice cream with graham cracker revel swirled throughout.
Key Lime Pie
Lemon flavored ice cream with egg yolks added for a richer flavor.
Tropical mango ice cream mixed with a sweet raspberry swirl.
Mint ice cream mixed with a minty chocolate cookie revel and packed with chunks of OREO®.
Mint Cookie Crunch
Peach flavored ice cream with real peach fruit pieces and a rich caramel swirl.
Peaches & Caramel
A sweet, smooth and decadent pistachio ice cream accented with pieces of pistachio, almond and pineapple.
White chocolate flavored ice cream with cream cheese frosted homemade red velvet cake.
Red Velvet Cake
Lightly salted peanut butter flavored ice cream with a graham cracker swirl throughout.
Salted Peanut Butter Pie
Sea salt toffee flavored ice cream loaded with Heath bar pieces
Sea Salt Toffee
Blueberry cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry swirls.
Super Blueberry Cheesecake
Vanilla ice cream with a caramel swirl, mixed with chocolate covered caramel cups and pecans.
All Trademarks Are Property Of Their Respective Owners
We serve products containing: wheat, milk, eggs, treenuts, peanuts, soy and gluten. When ordering made-to-order items at one of our locations, please inform us if you have a food allergy, intolerance or sensitivity when you order. We cannot guarantee that cross-contact will not occur with these foods in the store.
Shakes & Malts
Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Cherry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Peach, Banana*, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Pina Colada, Butterscotch, Lime, Lemon, Orange, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Marshmallow, Crème de Menthe, Blueberry, Root Beer, Hot Fudge*, KONA® Coffee, Cake Batter®*, Sugar Cone*
SM $4.00 MED $4.30 LG $4.70
SM $4.30 MED $4.60 LG $5.00 *
Butterfinger®, OREO®, Snickers®, Twix®, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup®, Kit Kat®, M&M’s® (Plain or Peanut), Reese’s Pieces®, Black Cherry, Cherry Bon Bon*, Heath®, Turtle*, Praline Pecan*, Banana Split* (large only), Fudge Brownie*, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
SM $5.00 MED $5.30 LG $5.70
SM $5.25 MED $5.55 LG $5.95 *
FLAVORED ICE CREAM
May we suggest: Chocolate Chip, Mint Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Peanut Butter Revel, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Graham Central Station, Strawberry Cheesecake, Butter Pecan, Moose Tracks®
SM $5.50 MED $5.80 LG $6.20
Dips of Ice Cream
Due to COVID-19, we currently are not offering cones. All dips will be served in a cup.
Mini Dip $2.20 1-DIP $2.80 2-DIP $4.65 3-DIP $6.10
Flavor Flight (four mini-sized dips) $5.25
Dairy-Free Chocolate Mint $0.50 extra per dip
Chocolate, Pineapple, Butterscotch, Peach, Strawberry, Marshmallow, Raspberry, Crème de Menthe
1-DIP $3.80 2-DIP $5.55 3-DIP $7.05
Hot Fudge $0.30 Extra
Nuts & Whipped Cream $0.85 Extra
Turtle 1-DIP $4.60 2-DIP $6.35
Tin Roof 1-DIP $4.20 2-DIP $6.05
Cherry Bon Bon 1-DIP $4.60 2-DIP $6.35
Brownie Under 1-DIP $5.75 2-DIP $7.45
Dusty Road 1-DIP $4.05 2-DIP $5.80
S'more 1-DIP $4.50 2-DIP $6.25
1-DIP $4.80 2-DIP $6.55 3-DIP $8.05
A malt or shake with a sundae on top – large only
Regular Boston $6.65
Hot Fudge Boston $6.95
Double Fudge Boston $7.25
Flavored Ice Cream $8.15
Sodas & Floats
Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Pineapple, Root Beer, Cherry, Lime, Orange, Crème de Menthe, Blueberry, Lemon
SM $4.00 MED $5.75 LG $7.15
Pop Float SM $3.80 MED $5.55 LG $6.95
Slush Float SM $4.00 MED $5.75 LG $7.15
SHERBET FREEZES SM $4.75 MED $5.05 LG $5.45
REGULAR FREEZES LG $4.70
Vanilla, Chocolate, Root Beer, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Strawberry, Cherry
Strawberry, Red Raspberry, Peach, Pineapple, Blueberry, Banana, Mandarin Orange, Red Cherry, Black Cherry, Cream Cheese, Chocolate OREO®, Chocolate
Cones & Dishes SM $3.80 LG $6.50
Shakes SM $5.25 MED $5.55 LG $5.95
Packages Pint $7.90 Quart $12.75
Strawberry Berry - Orange Juice & Strawberries
Three Berry Blend - Orange Juice, Strawberries, Raspberry & Blueberry
Razzle Dazzle - Orange Juice, Strawberries, Raspberries & Banana
Banana Split - Orange Juice, Strawberry, Pineapple & Banana
MED $4.05 LG $4.45
Yogurt / Ice Cream Smoothie $1.00 Extra
Chippers & Mint Chippers $3.49
Dixie Cups $0.75 each, $7.50 per dozen
Mini Malts $1.99
Chocolate Malt, Cookies n' Cream, Moose Tracks, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
SM $1.10 MED $1.35 LG $1.75
SM $1.50 MED $1.90 LG $2.25
Hand Packed Pint $6.25 (Dairy-Free $7.25)
Hand Packed Quart $10.25 (Dairy-Free $12.25)
Pre-Packaged Pint $2.99
Pre-Packaged Quart $4.49
Pre-Packaged 1.75 Quart $6.29
Prices may vary upon store location.