2024 Retro Flavor Madness

And the winner is….

PEANUT BUTTER OREO FUDGE!!!!!!!

Thanks to everyone who voted in our Retro Flavor Madness bracket this year. We will be brining back this winning flavor sometime this spring – stay tuned for more details!

Red Line Page Break

It’s RETRO FLAVOR MADNESS time! Since last year’s Flavor Madness bracket was so popular, we decided to determine the favorite retired flavor! Pick your winners at the link below for them to move on to the next round! At the end of the month, the final flavor will be named the champion and will come BACK IN STORES for a limited time later this spring!

The dates for the remainder of the contest: 32 flavors (March 8-11), 16 flavors (March 12-15), 8 flavors (March 16-18), 4 flavors (March 19-23) and the final 2 (March 24-27). The winner will be announced on March 28.

(We know there are a lot more flavors everyone loves, but we only included the flavors that we are still able to make. Thanks for your understanding!)