Excited to introduce our NEW Key Lime Ice Cream Pie! This delicious, springtime dessert features a graham cracker crust filled with our Key Lime Pie ice cream and finished with whipped topping.
Available starting today at all nine Whitey’s locations, and in local grocery stores where Whitey’s is sold by the end of the week!
locustDue to a construction project, our Locust Street store in Davenport will be closed on Tuesday, March 24 and opening again at 10am on Wednesday, March 25. We are sorry for this inconvenience and hope you’ll visit one of our other eight stores in the meantime! Thank you for your understanding.
It’s the first official day of Spring, and our Spring Flavors are blooming! The flavors available today at our stores include Key Lime Pie, Super Blueberry Cheesecake, Mango Raspberry and Lemon Custard! Stop by any of our nine locations to try one today!
KEY LIME PIE – Lime flavored ice cream with graham cracker revel swirled throughout.
SUPER BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE – Blueberry cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry swirls.
The 2026 Shake Madness winner is….
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Shakes and Malts will be on sale at all of our stores from Friday, March 27 through Tuesday, March 31 for the price of a Regular Shake. Stop by and celebrate the winner with us!
Thanks for following along and joining in on the 2026 Shake Madness contest!
This year we’re shakin’ up our annual Flavor Madness competition! The 2026 bracket has arrived, and we are determining the best Shake at Whitey’s Ice Cream!
Pick your winners at the link below for them to move on to the next round. At the end of the month, the winning shake will be named the champion and will be on sale for a limited time!
We can’t include every shake option available, but let us know which is your favorite of the options listed. Also, don’t worry, this includes Shakes AND Malts.
The dates for the contest: 32 flavors (March 9-12), 16 flavors (March 13-16), 8 flavors (March 17-20), 4 flavors (March 21-23) and the final 2 (March 24-26). The winner will be announced on Friday, March 27 and will be on sale from Friday, March 27 through Tuesday, March 31.
Mint Cookie Crunch is back in stores! This popular flavor is mint ice cream, mixed with a minty-chocolate cookie revel and packed with chunks of OREO.
Pick up a scoop at any of our nine locations today!
DOUBLE YOUR DOUGH, with Salted Brown Butter Cookie Dough!
The March Treat of the Month celebrates our 2025’s “Flavor Madness” winner with buy one scoop, get the second FREE!
Salted Brown Butter Cookie Dough features salted brown butter ice cream loaded with cookie dough pieces and swirled with a buttery, brown sugar and cinnamon ribbon.
Only valid for one and two scoop orders of Salted Brown Butter Cookie Dough.
